Question:
What is the best Lou Reed album. Is the old stuff the best ?
jackbentley9
2007-08-16 21:34:20 UTC
What is the best Lou Reed album. Is the old stuff the best ?
Five answers:
deadhead (Who Dat Nation)
2007-08-16 22:13:50 UTC
Some of his solo material was alright, but for my money I would go with Velvet Underground which had Lou Reed.
Bowzer
2007-08-17 05:28:56 UTC
By far, actually.



His post-Velvet career has been very patchy - he's made the occasional great song, rather than the great album. Of his solo work, I would recommend:



Transformer (1972) - the famous one. It's lots of fun.

Berlin (1973) - dark, challenging.

Coney Island Baby (1976) - lightweight at times. The title track is very evocative and nostalgic though.

Street Hassle (1978) - Gritty. Title track is a mini-opera that I rate among his best stuff, with a little cameo by Bruce Springsteen.

New York (1989) - Went gold. Some rate it high, I find it short on ideas.

Songs For Drella (with John Cale) (1990) - tribute to Andy Warhol. Often moving, and Cale's viola adds a little something to some of the songs.

Magic & Loss (1992) - Ponderous. The song "Harry's Circumcision" is utterly brilliant, though.

Set The Twilight Reeling (1996) - Maybe 3 good songs, lots of filler.

Ecstasy (2000) - Ditto. But a harder edge to the sound.

The Raven (2003) - Interesting take on Edgar Allan Poe.



These are the live albums:



Rock n Roll Animal (1974) US #45, Gold

Lou Reed Live (1975) US #62

Live: Take No Prisoners (1978)

Live in Italy (1984)

Beauty And Rust (Live in Leysin) (1992)

Live in Concert (A re-issue of the album Live in Italy ) (1996)

Perfect Night: Live in London (1998)

American Poet (2001)

Animal Serenade (2004)



None of them really essential. Nice to have, maybe.



On the whole, like John Lennon, he did much of his best work in the context of a group.
anonymous
2007-08-17 12:07:45 UTC
In my opinion, Rock and Roll Animal. The 'Prelude' to 'Sweet Jane' is an amazing display of dual guitar leads and one of the greatest rock instrumentals in history!
GAH1949
2007-08-19 03:45:47 UTC
My favorites are "The Vevet Underground and Nico", "Loaded", also by the Velvet Underground, and "New York".
Just another Y!A liar.
2007-08-18 03:04:18 UTC
"Transformer" and "Berlin" are both solid. otherwise, the man's solo work pales in comparison to both the Velvets' recordings and former compatriot John Cale's solo material...


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...